Cyber insurance in 2026: Five assumptions worth questioning
October is Cyber Security Awareness Month, a good time to test the assumptions your business makes about cyber risk and how you would respond if an incident occurred.
A compromised email, fraudulent invoice or ransomware attack can disrupt businesses of any size. While technology helps protect against these threats, it is easy to overlook gaps in how your business would respond and recover.
Cyber insurance can form part of your response and recovery arrangements, alongside strong security controls and incident planning.
Here are five common assumptions worth reconsidering:
- “We’re too small to be a target.”
Cyber incidents aren’t limited to large organisations. Any business that relies on email, digital payments or sensitive information can be exposed to cybercrime.
The financial impact can also be significant. According to the Australian Signals Directorate’s Annual Cyber Threat Report 2025–26, the average self-reported cost of cybercrime for small businesses was $55,400 per report.
For a small business, an unexpected loss, combined with the time and resources needed to recover, can place considerable pressure on operations and cash flow.
-
“Our IT provider has cybersecurity covered.”
Your IT provider plays an important role in protecting your systems, but managing the consequences of a cyber incident can extend beyond technology.
Investigating what happened, assessing legal obligations, communicating with customers and managing business interruption may require additional specialist support.
Cyber insurance may provide access to specialist incident response services, including IT forensic experts, legal advisers and crisis communications support, depending on the policy.
Do you know who would manage your business’s response to a cyber incident?
-
“Our data is in the cloud, so it’s safe.”
Cloud storage offers security benefits, but it doesn’t eliminate cyber risk.
Compromised accounts and third-party providers can still expose sensitive business information, while the growing use of AI tools introduces additional data security considerations.
Do you know who has access to your business data and where it’s stored?
-
“Our existing business insurance will cover a cyber incident.”
Not all business insurance policies cover cyber-related losses. Costs associated with data recovery, business interruption and fraudulent payments may require specific cyber insurance cover.
Even dedicated cyber policies can have different limits and conditions for certain incidents, particularly payment fraud.
When reviewing cover, consider:
- Whether payment fraud is included
- Overall policy limits
- Applicable excesses and business interruption waiting periods
- Cover for incidents affecting cloud and other service providers
- Exclusions that may affect a claim
When did you last review what your insurance actually covers?
-
“If something happens, we’ll just restore our systems.”
Backups are important, but recovering from a cyber incident can involve more than restoring data. Even where backups are available, restoring systems safely and confirming that the threat has been contained can take time.
Lost revenue, legal obligations, customer communications and reputational damage can all affect business recovery.
Cyber insurance may provide access to specialist response services and cover certain recovery costs, subject to policy terms and conditions.
Are your backups tested, and do you know who to call first?
Be ready before an incident happens
A few practical steps can strengthen your cyber resilience:
- Protect: Use multi-factor authentication (MFA), keep systems updated and train staff to recognise suspicious emails and payment requests.
- Prepare: Confirm backups can be restored and establish an incident response plan. Keep key contacts accessible, including your IT provider, internal decision-makers, insurance broker and insurer’s incident response service.
- Review: Assess your financial exposure and whether your cyber insurance reflects your business’s operations and risks. Pay particular attention to payment fraud limits, excesses, waiting periods and policy conditions.
Is your cyber cover keeping pace?
At Centrewest Insurance Brokers, we help businesses understand their cyber exposures, review existing insurance arrangements and explore cover suited to their operations and risk profile.
Contact Centrewest to discuss your cyber insurance arrangements.
This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice or consider your specific circumstances. Insurance cover depends on the terms, conditions, limits and exclusions of individual policies.